Best Framing Nailer Review and Shootout – New Updates!
Finding the best framing nailer for your work means different things to different Pros. Are you a framer or a remodeler? Is price the biggest issue, or is it driving power, weight, or recoil? No matter what your priorities, chances are our Pro team has considered it in this head to head shootout.
Of course, we put our heads together to take this comprehensive list and rank each model at the end. As a bonus, we brought in 4 models that don’t require a hose. Buckle your seatbelt – here we go!
Editor’s Note: This article was originally published on July 26, 2018.
Editor’s Note: Hitachi’s NR90AE(S1) didn’t make in time for our initial tests, but it arrived and we have updated the results to reflect its performance. The shootout was originally published on June 25, 2018.
Best Framing Nailer Starting List
While we invited more brands to participate, here are the models that came in for testing:
- Bostitch F21PL2
- DeWalt DWF83PL
- Estwing EFR2190
- Hitachi NR83A5
- Hitachi NR90AE(S1)
- Makita AN923
- Milwaukee 7200-20
- Paslode F350-S
- Ridgid R350RHF
- Senco 325FRHXP
- Bositch 20V Max BCF30PTM1
- DeWalt 20V Max DCN692M1
- Hitachi 18V NR1890DR
- Paslode Cordless XP CF325XP
Features that Matter
There are features, but some make a bigger impact than others. Here’s what our team looks for and which models have them.
Rafter Hook
This one is pretty obvious inclusion and it shows – every model we tested except the Hitachi NR90AE(S1) includes a rafter hook. Some are better than others, but most are pretty standard. The Hitachi 18V hook is big enough to straddle a 4 x4 – and get in the way. Hitachi’s NR83A5 doesn’t swivel while Estwing’s swings freely.
Metal Magazine
Plastic magazines tend to work more sluggishly than the crisp action of a good metal magazine. All of our pneumatic framing nailers have metal magazines and all of the cordless models have plastic.
Adjustable Exhaust
As the nailer fires, exhaust has to go somewhere. Most Pros prefer to turn the exhaust port away from their faces to avoid have that quick blast of air deliver a small particle into their eyes.
Who Has it
- Bostitch
- Milwaukee
Who Doesn’t
- DeWalt
- Estwing
- Hitachi NR83
- Hitachi NR90
- Makita
- Paslode
- Ridgid
- Senco
- Bostitch 20V Max
- DeWalt 20V Max
- Hitachi 18V
- Paslode Cordless XP
Tool-Free Mode Change
In the best case scenario, you flip a switch to change between single fire and bump fire modes. Some of our nailers make it that easy. Some have a two-step process for safety reasons, but a couple require a complete trigger change – something our team hates.
Who Has It
- DeWalt (2-stage flipper switch)
- Estwing (2-stage flipper switch)
- Hitachi NR83 (on-trigger slide mechanism)
- Hitachi NR90 (1-stage flipper switch)
- Makita (1-stage flipper switch)
- Milwaukee (2-stage flipper switch)
- Ridgid (1-stage flipper switch)
- Senco (slide mechansim above the trigger)
- Bostitch 20V Max (1-stage switch)
- DeWalt 20V Max (1-stage switch)
- Hitachi 18V (electronic button)
Who Doesn’t
- Bostitch (trigger change needed)
- Paslode (trigger change needed)
* The Paslode Cordless XP model only has single fire mode
Dry Fire Lockout
Dry fire lockout helps prevent damage to the driver blade and reminds you to add more nails before you a run a line without nailing anything. In an ideal world, lockout would happen once the last nail is fired, but even the best framing nailer leaves a few in the magazine.
Who Has It
- Estwing (4 nails remaining)
- Makita (4 nails remaining)
- Milwaukee (5 nails remaining)
- Ridgid (5 nails remaining)
- Bostitch 20V Max (9 nails remaining)
- DeWalt 20V Max (9 nails remaining)
- Hitachi 18V (5 nails remaining)
- Paslode Gas (5 nails remaining)
Who Doesn’t
- Bostitch
- Dewalt
- Hitachi NR83
- Hitachi NR90
- Paslode
- Senco
Editor’s Note: We originally reported that Estwing does not have dry fire lockout when, in fact, it does.
Cordless/Hoseless
Not having a hose to drag around is a huge advantage for cordless/hoseless nailers. There are some trade-offs like weight and capacity, but they’re worth making for remodelers and punch list work.
- Bostitch 20V Max
- DeWalt 20V Max
- Hitachi 18V
- Paslode Cordless XP (battery + fuel cell)
Next Up: Diving Deeper
Okay reality check on toenailing… Milwaukee 7200-20 NO (cant drive fastener completely) – Hitachi NR90AE(S1) NO (cant toe at all, the head is crap and gets no gription) – Ridgid R350RHF NO (cant drive fastener completely) – Bostitch F21PL2 YES (unfortunately the depth adjustment is crap and can only be used at full depth, [it will reset itself there at random], great for toenailing though
Now throw out all nailers that won’t take 3 1/2″ .131.
Why did you not include the Max framing nailer in the comparison test? Surely a worthwhile competitor?
FYI, compare the old 2005 era Ridgid R350RH(a) to the Milwaukee and you’ll notice they are nearly identical
I wonder why didn’t Milwaukee Cordless model make the list?