Best OSHA-Compliant Dust Extractor Shootout News & Opinion

CFM vs Water Lift on a Dust Extractor


In our recent dust extractor shootout among OSHA-compliant models, two number were of great importance to us: CFM and water lift. But when it comes to CFM vs water lift on a dust extractor, what’s more important?

The answer is both.

SUPPORT OUR ADVERTISERS

Related Content

CFM vs Water Lift on a Dust Extractor

Understanding CFM

CFM seems to be the sexy number to toss around for both dust extractors and blowers. In both kinds of tools (and vacuum cleaners, for that matter), CFM stands for Cubic Feet per Minute and is a measure of how much air the motor pulls through every minute.

Let’s take Makita’s VC4710 dust extractor as an example. It has 135 CFM. In other words, every minute it pulls enough air to fill a cube that measures roughly 5.1′ on every side. Now that’s pretty helpful – if everything you’re trying to collect is floating around in the air.

CFM vs Water Lift on a Dust Extractor

 

Essentially, CFM is what keeps material moving once you have it going. The larger your CFM value, the larger area your dust extractor will influence during use.

CFM vs Water Lift on a Dust Extractor

Understanding Water Lift

The suction force measurement can take on several forms, but you’ll usually see it as water lift or some form of a pressure rating. A quick Google search will allow you to convert pressure measurements into water lift – just make sure you double check the units to get the correct conversion.

Water lift measures the amount of lifting force the vacuum has. As the motor pulls water up a tube, gravity tries to pull the weight of the water back down. Eventually, they meet in the middle when the dust extractor holds all the weight it can. It’s not uncommon for dust extractor like the ones in our shootout to be able to pull 90″ – 100″ in a static water lift test.

CFM vs Water Lift on a Dust Extractor

Note – the diameter of the tube makes a difference, so you’ll notice our shootout results are based on a 2-1/2″ OD tube and don’t match the manufacturer’s stated test results.

The importance of water lift is that the stronger the pull, the larger the debris your dust extractor can collect. So when I said CFM is great for all the debris floating around in the air, it is. But you need suction force to get anything that’s not floating around moving.

Here’s the crazy thing – that suction force needs to be really close to what it’s collecting. Our dust extractors will start to pick up sawdust from the floor when it gets around 1-1/2″ away from it and concrete dust closer to 1″ away. But it’s most effective when the nozzle is a mere 1/2″ away from what you want to collect. So the smaller or lighter the particle, the easier time your dust extractor has collecting it, but proximity is critical as particles grow in size.

SUPPORT OUR ADVERTISERS

The Final Word on CFM Vs Water Lift on a Dust Extractor

CFM and water lift have to work together to make an effective dust extractor. Obviously, the higher the number, the better for both values. But like we saw in our cordless blower shootout, a balance of the two is better than having one rating high and the other low. So don’t be fooled by just looking for the biggest CFM number you can find. Compare the suction force (water lift, pressure) value as well to see which one has the best balance of both for the class you’re considering.

2
Leave a Reply

avatar
1 Comment threads
1 Thread replies
1 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
2 Comment authors
Kenny KoehlerDavid S Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
David S
Guest
David S

Is there a ratio that you want to look for in making your choice? Or is the selection of CFM vs water lift dependent on your specific needs? I’m guessing the latter.