fbpx
March 7, 2021

Professional Tool Reviews for Pros


Porter-Cable Oscillating Tool Review – PCE605K

Pro Rating
  • Cutting Speed 8.3
  • Vibration Control 8
  • Accessory Change 9
  • Ergonomics 8.4
  • Noise Level 6.3
  • Value 9.3

For a brand that's generally considered to exist in the prosumer sphere of the market, Porter-Cable exceeds our expectations and leaves several members of our testing team with the impression that this is a tool they're willing to reach for. 

Overall Score 8.2 (out of 10)

We recently took 26 corded and cordless oscillating multitool models and compared them next to each other to see who makes the fastest oscillating, most comfortable, easiest-to-use multi-tool that presents the best value. If you’re curious about how it all turned out, check out the full details of our Oscillating Multitool Shootout. As is the tradition around here, we’re taking a look at each of our individual entries. Today, we’re putting the corded Porter-Cable oscillating tool under the microscope.


Pros

  • Excellent value
  • Excellent blade change system
  • Better performance than we expect from a Prosumer brand

Cons

  • Loud
  • Not a model to compete with the top performers in the multi-tool space

Recommendation

This is an excellent choice for serious DIYers, Prosumers, and Pros that need an oscillating multi-tool occasionally. While it doesn’t compete with Fein, it gives you a lot of performance for the price and has one of the best ergonomic designs.

Blade Changes

The Porter-Cable oscillating tool uses a pretty solid tool-less accessory change system. Instead of horsing around with wrenches and bolts to change out blades, you’ll simply pull up on a lever to release the blade clamp. It works simply and efficiently, and though it’s not quite as slick as the Starlock system that both Fein and Bosch have developed, we have no complaints.

Ergonomics

The Porter-Cable oscillating tool has some good things going for it from an ergonomic perspective. First of all, it weighs in at 3.23 lbs. We tested some lighter models, but we also tested models that were quite a bit heavier. Weight factors into the comfortability scale more on the longer jobs, but even on those smaller cuts, a lighter tool usually equals a more maneuverable tool.

Porter-Cable designed this oscillating tool with a barrel grip. The handle also has some grippy overmolding at the front, middle, and back of the tool. Overall, the tool feels relatively comfortable to hold onto, with the size, weight, and rubber grips playing a big part. A bit more contouring might help even further, but to be fair, we didn’t test a lot of multi-tools that really emphasize a contoured handle, and this is one of the more comfortable designs in the shootout.

Performance

The Porter-Cable oscillating tool features a 3-amp motor and a 2.8° oscillation angle. You can adjust the speed using the variable speed dial on the back of the tool, and it has an available range of 10,000-22,000 OPM. This multi-tool also features a lock-on switch, as opposed to a variable speed trigger, which is helpful for longer cuts.

As far as speed goes, the Porter-Cable oscillating tool didn’t disappoint, but it also didn’t blaze through cuts like a few of the models did. It finished in the middle of the pack, but aside from the far ends of the ranges, the differences in cutting speeds amongst the tools we tested fell within ten seconds of each other.

One thing that’s unique to the Porter-Cable oscillating tool is the depth and cutting guide. We didn’t see this with any of the other models, but this attachment could find a lot of use with plunge cutting applications.

Vibration

Again, this is one of those areas where the Porter-Cable oscillating tool finished in the middle of the table. Its vibration control was about what you should expect from any professional level multi-tool, but it didn’t go above and beyond in this category. Still, we tested some models that really disappointed on this front, but Porter-Cable holds its own here. Running this tool for longer periods of time won’t cause any undue numbness or discomfort that you’ll get from some of the cheap models.

Noise

The Porter-Cable oscillating tool probably will you to keep ear protection on hand, er, on ear. We measured decibel levels at the ear while the tool was in use, and this one cranked out 101 dB(A). None of the tools we looked at were necessarily quiet, but this one thumbs its nose a bit at the idea of keeping its voice down.

Understanding Hearing Protection with DeWalt

Value

At $129, the Porter-Cable oscillating tool presents a pretty great value. It’s comfortable, it has a great accessory change system, and it cranks out the type of performance we expect from a Pro-level tool. Plus, it comes with a depth gauge that we didn’t see on any other model. It retails for less than many of its competitors and comes with a 3-year warranty.

 

Included In Kit

  • Oscillating tool
  • Depth/cutting guide
  • Precision wood end-cut blade
  • Wood/metal end-cut blade
  • Flush-cut blade
  • Sanding plate
  • 25 sandpaper sheets
  • Flexible scraper
  • Storage case

Final Thoughts

We’ll be honest here, the Porter-Cable oscillating tool impressed us in our shootout. Even though it finishes in 9th place overall, it beat out some big names like DeWalt, Hitachi, Bosch, and Milwaukee. For a brand that’s generally considered to exist in the prosumer sphere of the market, this tool exceeds our expectations and leaves several members of our testing team with the impression that this is a tool they’re willing to reach for.

The potential downside is that its future is in question with Stanley Black and Decker’s relaunch of Craftsman.

Porter-Cable Oscillating Tool Features

  • 3 Amp Motor delivers power to complete applications fast
  • Tool Free System: blade change allows quick changes and adjustments for specific applications without wrenches and bolts
  • Depth and Cutting Guide helps complete plunge and cutting tasks faster and with more control
  • Variable Speed Dial (10,000 – 22,000 OPM) optimizes performance and control across a complete range of applications
  • 3 Position Over Mold provides a gripping area on the front, middle and rear to improve comfort by reducing vibration
  • 10 Foot Cord minimizes the need for extension cords

Porter-Cable Oscillating Tool Specifications

  • Model: Porter-Cable PCE605K
  • Power Source: 120V
  • Motor Size: 3.0 Amp
  • Oscillations: 10,000-22,000 OPM
  • Oscillation Angle: 2.8 degrees
  • Weight: 3.7 lbs.
  • Length: 11″
  • Warranty: 3 years limited
  • Price: $79.49
Shop Amazon

 

 

Related articles

Rockwell RK5100K SoniCrafter Oscillating Tool Preview

The SoniCrafter from Rockwell is a versatile and efficient multi-function tool. Featuring microsonic oscillation that will help give smooth cuts, this tool can be use for all kinds of cutting, sawing, scraping, shaping, polishing and removing grout. Since there is an extensive line of accessories available from Rockwell there should be no problems with working in materials such as plastic, masonry, tile, fiberglass and wood.

Dremel Multi-Max 6300 Oscillating Tool Kit Review

Anyone who is even minimally into tools has heard of Dremel. They make all sorts of polishing and cutting tools based on a rotary design. When Fein’s exclusive patent on their oscillating tool expired last year and other manufacturers were allowed to manufacture similar devices, Dremel was first on-board. Sure, an oscillating tool only rotates a total of 3 degrees, but it’s still technically a rotary tool, right? Not really, but who cares, these are very cool tools that do things no other tools on the market can do. With Dremel bringing theirs to market at under $100, they have made this tool very accessible to consumers.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Keith Pomeraning

I’ve had a PC multitool for years which has worked well … the only drawback has been the Bosch and most of the “universal” blades don’t properly fit. Those times you’re cranking out a project and find out you’re short a blade or two, the easily found Bosch or universal blades versus the harder-to-find PC blades can make a difference.

Dominick Moglia

I have one for sale in hard case minimal use 65shipped went cordless lol

2
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x