fbpx
October 17, 2021

Professional Tool Reviews for Pros


Corded vs Cordless Tools – Which is Better?

corded vs cordless tools which better

We talk about the cordless job site pretty frequently. But in the corded vs cordless tools question—can battery truly render the cord obsolete? The math doesn’t add up, right? Actually, it does. As manufacturers push into more powerful cordless tools, the concept of switching out your corded tools without power trade-offs is compelling.


You Have to Do the Math

We had to stop and think when asked how can cordless tools replace corded tools? The math didn’t—at first glance—seem to add up. The initial question came through on our Milwaukee RedLithium High Output Battery article, and it’s a really good one. Here’s the rationale:

120 volts x 15 amps = 1800 total watts

18 volts x 15 amps = 270 total watts

or even…

36 volts x 15 amps = 540 total watts

…and we can keep going, of course. Any cordless tool producing 15 amps can’t possibly be as powerful as a 15-amp corded model. There must be something more.

There is—and we see it with both automotive and marine batteries. These often produce over 1000 cranking amps from a 12V product! In reality, they can technically produce these amps with just 7.2 volts!

Corded vs Cordless Tools and How They Use Current

So how can cordless tools replace corded tools and have the same power capabilities? They use or produce more current. Much more. Running as many as 100 amps to power a tool seems awfully high, but that’s exactly what’s going on in the battery.

18 volts x 100 amps = 1800 total watts

Notice that as you increase the voltage, the extra current you need comes down.

36 volts x 50 amps = 1800 watts

In order for the battery pack to only provide 15 amps of current to match what you get out of the wall, it would also have to be wired for 120 volts (DC).

Why Can’t You Just Make a 120V Battery?

Keep in mind that many manufacturers list a “Max voltage“, which is the voltage at the pack’s highest charge state. It quickly drops ~10% down to its “nominal” voltage where it operates most of the time. So, you’re looking at a tool that would be 133V Max to match the 120V coming out of your wall.


In case it comes up on Final Jeopardy, that would be sets of 37 cells!

While some outdoor power equipment does indeed run at 120V (Max), it probably doesn’t need to. Some increase in voltage helps, but modern battery packs can handle the higher current output.

What’s Next in the Corded vs Cordless Tools Future?

First: Battery Cells with More Power Density

When I spoke with Paul Fry, Cordless Guru for Milwaukee Tool (my title for him, his official title is VP of Product Management), he gave me a little more insight into how cordless tools are replacing corded tools. He said the original batch of lithium-ion tools that came out years ago could only produce a few hundred watts out. With better cell and tool technology, manufacturers can now produce a few thousand watts out.

And it only gets better when you factor in improvements like new 21700 lithium-ion battery cells.

Bosch Eneracer battery 20700 cells

Second: More Rows of Cells Equals Less Current Per Cell

The question used to be how to manage high current output with enough runtime. Getting 1800 watts to exceed 15-amp corded tools is not only doable, but it’s also effective. Manufacturers have now made significant strides in run-time thanks to better cell technology. We’re also seeing larger battery packs that use as many as three parallel rows of cells.

The primary difference between an 18V pack with 5 cells and one with 15 cells is three-fold:

  • 5-cell packs have to generate all that current from just 5 cells. The 15-cell pack distributes it across 3X as many cells.
  • 15-cell packs generate more overall heat—even though the individual cells are taxed less. That center row of cells needs to “breathe”.
  • 15-cell packs run longer due to more capacity AND having that capacity spread across a higher number of Lithium-ion cells.
Milwaukee 12.0 Ah High Output Battery 03

Third: The Future Looks Bright

The future could hold additional improvements as well. We’re seeing news of solid-state battery technology and the use of graphene technology in lithium-ion to improve charging speeds. The use of silicon also promises faster charging and greater power density for all Lithium-ion battery types. This could also yield more output beyond what you can get from a typical 15A wall circuit.

Related articles

Choosing a Rotary Laser Level for Professional Use

Even if you’re not a professional tradesman, the chances are you’ve probably used a traditional spirit level around the house. You set the level on the surface you’d like to level and adjust until the bubble is between the lines. This bubble or spirit level has been used for hundreds of years. But do you ever […]

What is OSHA – Understanding Their Mission

What is OSHA? If you’ve been keeping up with the content of this site for the last few months, you might’ve seen an uptick in articles regarding the government watchdog agency. The reason for this mostly comes down to the current OSHA regulations involving silica dust permissible exposure limit. Because of the new guidelines, manufacturers […]

DeWalt PowerStack Batteries and Technology

Designed with stacked pouch battery cells instead of cylindrical cells, DeWalt PowerStack 20V Max batteries make some huge changes. DeWalt claims PowerStack batteries and technology provide more power with less weight and size. They give the case in point with their debut model, the DeWalt DCBP034 PowerStack 1.7Ah battery. This might be the biggest announcement […]

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
6 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Jeremiah McKenna

Something else to consider is the major safety benefits of a cordless tool. Drop it in water, no one is electrocuted. Release the trigger and the blades/bits etc. stop spinning/moving almost instantly. On top of that, we have the “Roll out, Roll up” time saver. When you add up all the time it takes when you get to the job every morning, of rolling out the cords and hoses, filling the air, if using a generator you need to fill it with gas, all of this adds a lot of time before you can drive one nail or cut one… Read more »

Big Richard

Quick edit: “So, you’re looking at a tool that would be 133V Max to match the 120V coming out of your wall.
In case it comes up on Final Jeopardy, that would be sets of 37 cells!”

Li-ion cells are generally rated at a nominal voltage of 3.6v, so 120v / 3.6v = 33.33333 cells. Let’s call it 34 cells for 122.4v, NOT 37 cells (you almost cost someone Final Jeopardy). The MAX designation comes from rating the cells at 4v, so the same hypothetical 34 cell battery would be 136v MAX.

Art

Great article explaining power is volts * amps!

A couple of extra points- circuit breakers are all derated by 20% so that if the breaker says 15 amps it’s only going to provide 80% of that. Looks like battery power won’t have this hard limit.

And secondly more current means larger wires, which means bigger and heavier motors and tools. This is what’s driving higher voltage batteries where the same power requires less amps. There’s also an advantage to deliver the amps right at the tool regarding conductor size.

6
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x