July 25, 2021

Professional Tool Reviews for Pros

General Contractors Now Responsible for Subcontractor OSHA Violations

General Contractors Now Responsible for Subcontractor OSHA Violations

The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans has ruled that general contractors can be held responsible for subcontractors that create OSHA violations.

10-Second Summary

  • New ruling clarifies that a “controlling employer” can be cited for violations created by its subcontractors
  • Includes violations that do not directly affect the controlling employer’s own employees
  • Reverses the 1981 Melerine v. Avondale Shipyards, Inc. ruling that employers only have to worry about their own employees

Subcontractor Violations are Now General Contractor Problems

If you’re familiar with OSHA, it’s no surprise that employers are responsible for maintaining safe work environments for their employees. Based on a 1981 ruling (Melerine v. Avondale Shipyards, Inc.), that’s where it ended. Other company’s employees were their own problem.

In a decision filed on November 26, 2018, that changes.

Here’s a breakdown of the scenario that triggered the change:

  • Hensel Phelps was contracted to build a new library for the City of Austin
  • They subcontracted Haynes Eaglin Watters, LLC for work on the project’s Seaholm Substation East Screen Wall
  • Haynes Eaglin Watters then subcontracted demo work to CVI Development, LLC
  • During the process, Haynes created a soil wall without adequate sloping or other protective measures that CVI employees were required to work around, exposing them to the risk of cave in

In this scenario, the subcontractor actually created the violation, but Hensel’s (the general contractor) and Haynes’ (subcontractor) employees were never exposed to the risk. The OSHA inspector only witnessed CVI employees in the risk area.

Under the old law, that’s CVI’s problem. What this new ruling does is place responsibility on the general contractor (controlling employer in legalese) since that company has control over the project and its progress.

What This Means for Your Business

The bottom line is that you as the general contractor hold ultimate responsibility for creating a safe work environment for your employees as well as employees of any company you subcontract.

If your subcontractor does work that exposes any company’s employees to risk, expect OSHA to go after the subcontractor for creating the hazard and your firm for allowing it.

Additional Thoughts

After reporting on OSHA’s top 10 violations for 2018, it seems like the numbers are way too low considering how many violations we see just in our small area of central Florida.

The takeaway – OSHA is more reactive than proactive. This story is no different considering it took an employee who reported the violation to OSHA to get their attention.

Related articles

Should I Buy a Drill or an Impact Driver?

Several of our readers have posed this common question to our staff: “Should I buy a drill or an impact driver?” That’s a great question and one that comes up pretty early in the apprenticeship training process. Here’s the short answer: If you can only afford one tool, buy a drill. However, get a 2-tool […]

How to Use a Reciprocating Saw Like a Pro

There’s probably no more useful saw for remodelers, plumbers, electricians, and homeowners than the reciprocating saw. It’s hard to imagine a jobsite without one. But that was the reality before the introduction of the Milwaukee SawZall—the trademarked name that became synonymous with reciprocating saws—in 1951. You might have already read our best corded reciprocating saw article. Regardless of […]

What is a GFCI Outlet and Where Do They Go?

Part of what Pros run into involves answering questions for homeowners. Here’s a question that comes up quite a bit: What is a GFCI outlet and where do they go? (or why do we need them?) We grabbed a couple of our resident Pros to help answer this question. We also dive into why you need […]

How to Use a Tap and Die to Create or Repair Threads

When using a tap and die set, it’s important to understand the terms. “Tapping” occurs when you cut, or recut threads into a hole or nut. Most auto mechanics and metalworkers have likely dealt with this issue. It may have occurred in the form of a stripped socket or cut-off bolt which needed re-threading. Learning how to use a tap […]

Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Bill Wood

I’ve been in construction my whole life always watched the subcontractors safety.

Bill Wood

Unions run NYC. Lot of union pay to play money there.

Scott Kahle

NY General Contractor’s insurance works the same way. The trial lawyers run the NY dems and the dems run NY.

David Jackson

Bill Hargreaves, Eric Wood


When a catastrophic event with severe injury or god forbid a fatality occurs, I can assure you that OSHA is the least of any company’s concerns (i.e. family lawsuits and your litigation costs, etc.)

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x