Best OSHA-Compliant Dust Extractor Shootout Dust Extractor Reviews

Makita VC4710 Dust Extractor Review


Portable Dust Extractors

Build Quality
Feature Set
CFM
Suction Power
Value
Final Thoughts

The Makita VC4710 was our winner for the value category, but that doesn't make this extractor a "budget" model. The Xtract Vac had excellent water lift ratings as well as the least amount of power loss during filter cleaning cycles.

Overall Score 4.3 Shootout Results

Get Yours Online

Acme Tools

If you’ve been picking up what OSHA has been laying down lately, then you’re probably already aware that the watchdog agency has implemented new guidelines regarding acceptable exposure limits to silica dust. While these new requirements can affect the designs of a good many tools used in masonry applications, dust extraction seems like a particularly affected area of the trade. That being the case, we recently looked at some of the leading manufacturer’s OSHA-compliant Dust Extractors in this past month’s shootout. Makita, who has been ahead of the curve with OSHA compliance, gave us the chance to take a look at one of their traditional portable models. The Makita VC4710 includes the features necessary to meet the new OSHA guidelines, as well as the power to meet the needs of professional applications.  With space for two HEPA filters and 12 amps of total power, the Makita VC4710 Xtract Vac will keep your worksite clean while keeping you out of dutch with OSHA.

Makita VC4710 Feature Set

One of the main requirements for OSHA compliance revolves around the inclusion of a HEPA filter. The filter needs to capture 99.97% of particles 0.3 microns and larger to be considered a HEPA filter. The Makita VC4710 has space for two optional HEPA filters, although the unit doesn’t ship with any and you’ll have to purchase them separately.

Makita VC4710

While OSHA also requires automatic filter cleaning on dust extractors, some models will have better systems than others. The Makita uses a reverse air flow method to clear out the filter every 15 seconds to extend the filter’s usefulness. However, the reverse air flow method can shorten the filter life or possibly allow a small amount of dust to escape. We didn’t see the latter in any of our testing and it’s too soon to know how much actual filter life we’ll get.

SUPPORT OUR ADVERTISERS

The Makita VC4710 also features pass-through power. It’s somewhat limited by allowing a max of 600 watts. But that’s not unusual and it’s a little higher than some of the extractors we’ve used.

Makita VC4710

The Makita VC4710 also has plenty of accessory storage toward the back of the unit. As far as having an effective hose and cord wrap, Makita has one of the better systems for the power cord. However, the hose storage left us wanting. Though to be fair, no one really tackled this area super effectively.

Makita VC4710

Power

When looking at dust extractors, companies will generally test their equipment while measuring CFM and water lift capabilities. The CFM tests look at the volume of air that the motor pulls through the hose. Water lift looks at the lifting power in a closed air system. Both measurements have importance in this field.

Suction

For the water lift test, we ran each dust extractor with a clean HEPA filter the first time through. The Makita VC4710 lifted water up 77.5″ through a 2-1/2″ pipe, finishing 2nd behind Hilti’s model. The really interesting thing about the Makita happened when we ran the same test after sucking up 20 lbs of concrete dust. Where every other dust extractor lost some performance, the Makita performed exactly the same. Plus, where other models lost some significant performance during their cleaning cycles, the Makita’s performance only dropped by 5%.

Makita VC4710

Volume

We used the same idea for our CFM tests, where we used a clean HEPA filter for the first run and then again after sucking concrete. When you look at the area that’s completely cleared, Makita is in the middle of the pack but drops to the bottom when you consider the outside edge of the cone where there was a smaller effect. That’s all great, but we’re talking about differences of 1/8″ or 1/16″ which isn’t much. The important thing is that the extractor is rated at 135 CFM – and that’s what you’ll use to determine what tools you can use with it per OSHA regulations.

Best OSHA-Compliant Dust Extractor Shootout

When we look at the amount of clearing area Makita does, it’s still doing enough work to absolutely be Pro-level. With its 135 CFM rating, it’s doing a little less work than the 150 CFM models – and that shouldn’t be a surprise.

However, 135 CFM means that you can only use a 5″ grinder instead of the 6″ OSHA-compliance that kicks in at the 150 CFM mark.


Makita VC4710

Final Thoughts

The Makita VC4710 has a lot going for it that makes it a worthy consideration for purchase. Should you find yourself in the market for an OSHA-approved dust extraction system, you might appreciate that this dust extractor represents the best value of any that we tested. Of course, it’s a fine choice for those Pros that aren’t in the concrete industry as well. Makita has priced the VC4710 at $529, which makes it about $70 cheaper than the next model up and $379 less than our most expensive! Unless you need more than 135 CFM, the price point makes this model a very attractive option.

 

SUPPORT OUR ADVERTISERS

Related Content

Makita VC4710 Extract Vac Features

  • Automatic Filter Cleaning System with blow-back feature is timed at set intervals to maintain filter performance for longer filter lifeMakita VC4710
  • Included: Efficient main nano filter set (captures 99.95% particles 2 microns and larger)
  • Optional: HEPA filter set is Certified to meet or exceed the efficiency standard (captures 99.97% of particulates .3 microns and larger) – certificate included
  • Onboard tool-activated outlet starts and stops vacuum with power tool usage
  • Soft start function for lower amp-draw at start-up
  • Variable speed control dial for a variety of applications
  • Motor chamber constructed of quality sound-absorbing materials resulting in a quiet operating sound level of 59 dB(A)
  • Utilizes precision lightweight motor components and efficient air ducting to produce a vacuum weight of only 27 lbs.
  • Integrated cord reel and hose brackets for operator convenience
  • Large, wide-set, urethane rear wheels create a lower center of gravity for better stability

Makita VC4710 Extract Vac Specs

  • Model: Makita VC4710
  • Motor: 12 Amps total (7 vac only)
  • CFM: 135
  • Tested Water Lift: 77.50″
  • Capacity: 9 gal (dry) / 8 gal (wet)
  • Hose Length: 16′
  • Cord Length: 24.6′
  • Price: $529.99
  • Warranty: 1 year

Leave a Reply

3 Comments on "Makita VC4710 Dust Extractor Review"

avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
BuilderJim
Guest
I found this “review” in looking to research additional dust extraction systems for my job sites. This piece is so poorly written it is difficult to read and does not actually state any more info than the manufacturers brochure. The author and editor of this verbose piece should try again. CFM ratings are next to useless without the other half of the picture. Please use the correct terminology when discussing and explaining a given machines vacuum power. The measurement should be listed and discussed as inches on the water column. I too would like to know where these are manufactured,… Read more »
Brybar
Guest
Why don’t the folks who engineer these vacuums, ESPECIALLY the HEPA vacs, design a cyclone pre-treatment stage into the system instead of forcing the filters to be the bottleneck in the system? Oh, maybe it’s so that you, the “consumer”, can get your wallet out and pay for their proprietary filters? Don’t tell me it would cost too much to do that… the little bit it would cost to add a cyclone would get paid for in just a few saved filters. When one of these tool companies decide to put the customer first and design a no-brainer cyclone into… Read more »
Mikey
Guest

Where are these made?